One of the more puzzling aspects of Southampton’s season so far has been the continued exclusion of Maya Yoshida from Mark Hughes’ starting line-ups.
The Saints boss has elected to field a preferred central defensive partnership consisting of Wesley Hoedt and summer signing Jannik Vestergaard, two physically imposing but immobile players.
Hoedt has had an intriguing season. He started in shaky fashion, following his struggles throughout last term, but appeared to pick up some form in fixtures against Crystal Palace and Brighton and Hove Albion recently.
However, he seemed to return to his old tricks in his latest outing, as he turned in a substandard performance at Liverpool. He failed to react to a deflected cross and turned the ball into his own net for the opening goal of the game and proceeded to struggle with the pace of the match.
Hoedt appears to crumble when simple pressure is placed upon him. He is technically gifted, but he continues to be a liability in defensive phases. His positional awareness hasn’t improved since his arrival at the club, he still doesn’t appear to judge the flight of long balls well and, more concerningly, his lapses in concentration are costing Southampton. Hoedt is currently too reckless.

His fellow centre-back Jannik Vestergaard, however, has been in a similar vein of form. Patience is required with the Danish international because the stylistic differences between the Premier League and the Bundesliga are notable.
However, this does not mask the glaring reality that since his arrival, Vestergaard has done little to convince. He has impressed on occasions but has generally flattered to deceive; it is peculiar that the tallest outfield player in the Premier League has been comprehensively beaten to headers on two occasions that have led to goals.
It currently feels as though the impetus has been placed upon Vestergaard to solidify and command the defence. Although he has a brief experience of acting as a leader from his time in the Bundesliga, this is a big ask for a new signing. It begs the question, why has the experience of Maya Yoshida not been summoned to ease Vestergaard’s transition?
Yoshida, like several of his teammates, was poor last season. Despite this, though, it’d be a more than plausible statement to suggest that he was Saints’ best performing central defender.

Following such a strong World Cup campaign on an individual level with Japan, it comes as a big surprise to see Hughes neglect to utilise Yoshida, a player whose development was impressive until the negative influences of Mauricio Pellegrino came about.
Yoshida has made only one start for Southampton this season and this came in the Carabao Cup win against Brighton. He has been limited to a place on the bench throughout the early stages of the campaign in the Premier League, much to the dismay of Saints fans.
The experienced defender has been a shoo-in for Southampton’s starting line-up in the two seasons preceding the current campaign, yet he is currently being overlooked to accommodate two underperforming players. Hughes historically favours taller, more physically-gifted central defenders, but there is a clear lack of composure, mobility and leadership at the back right now.
A daunting upcoming fixture list awaits Saints and they’ll need to be at their very best defensively to avoid spiralling down the Premier League table. Yoshida may not be the answer to all of Southampton’s woes at the back, but his absence is peculiar to say the very least.









Comments.
Loading comments…