Much has been made about Southampton’s glaringly obvious defensive issues in the last few weeks, but now they face one of the greatest selection dilemmas in the club’s recent history.
After the sale of Jose Fonte and the injury sustained by Virgil van Dijk, Saints have been left in a rather challenging situation with a somewhat weakened defence. Maya Yoshida has been a mainstay in the side ever since Fonte’s departure, Jack Stephens has also filled the void left by the injured van Dijk and Florin Gardos has been waiting in the wings as a substitute.
However, the confirmation of Martin Caceres’ arrival on the south coast was finally upon us on Thursday evening, with the free agent joining on a short-term deal until the end of the 2016/17 campaign.

It was a signing that brought great relief to us fans, who have been voicing our concerns for some time now regarding the defensive depth within the squad.
Now, Caceres has joined up with the squad as they look to fully prepare for next weekend’s historic date at Wembley in the EFL Cup final against Manchester United.
The training camp out in Spain, for me, is a stroke of genius on the part of Southampton’s staff. It will provide us with the physical edge on United, it will bring the group even closer than before, it will bed the new signings in perfectly and it will, most importantly, define Caceres’ fitness for Claude Puel.
The burning topic of debate surrounding the clash at Wembley next Sunday comes through the centre-back position. Will Puel use Caceres or Stephens?
Without a doubt, Maya Yoshida will start the match. The Japan international has been in impressive form for the majority of the season and has most certainly earned his place in the final, having started and completed every single EFL Cup match in the lead-up to the game, and helping Saints to five consecutive clean sheets in the competition.

However, the choice of Caceres and Stephens is a far more challenging task for Puel to decide, and it’s going to be a highly interesting prospect when the team sheets are exchanged. There are both positives and negatives to either possibility (insert Claude Puel’s favourite word remark).
Firstly, we need to seriously consider Caceres. The 29-year-old absolutely oozes experience, and big-game experience at that. He’s played in World Cup’s, Copa America’s, Champions League games, Serie A games, La Liga games and Europa League games. His pedigree is superb, and that can only be proficient for the clash.
Along with his outstanding wealth of experience, Caceres’ ability is undeniable. He has superb technical ability and is a fantastic passer of the ball. We’ve missed precision and power at the back since Virgil’s injury and whilst Caceres may not portray the same physical prowess of the team captain, he certainly holds similar traits when it comes to having an eye for a pass.
However, the prominent question mark surrounding the Uruguayan international is his fitness. Will he be capable of playing a full match at Wembley against Zlatan Ibrahimovic and his Manchester United teammates on his first game for a new club?

Given that he last played a game of football 381 days ago, I’d say that it’d be a tremendously risky option to play him. Whilst his ability and capability cannot ever be denied, it’s a huge ask of a player that is sure to have next to no match fitness whatsoever.
It’s all well and good suggesting that he plays part of the final, but not the entirety of it, but is that not counter-productive? I can’t see the use in starting Caceres if he is only capable of playing for an hour at most. It would mean that a substitution could be required, in the form of Stephens or Gardos, and it isn’t really a position in which you’d want to alter things given the context of the occasion.
Rationality in team selection, proactivity and adaptability throughout the course of the match will be a big task for Claude Puel, and it’s something he has to be alert to.
Whilst it’s poignant that Caceres’ potential inclusion in the starting line-up would be a colossal risk, there are just as many question marks around whether or not Stephens is the right option. 
It’s been a massively turbulent 2017 so far for Stephens. He was called in to make his Premier League debut on the opening game of the year at right-back against Everton, and has since then been a regular feature in Saints’ starting line-up.
The England Under-21 international has made ten senior appearances for the club in his breakthrough season, and has had fairly mixed fortunes as well as mixed reviews during his emergence.
He was notably excellent against Liverpool in the second leg of the EFL Cup at Anfield, swooping the man of the match award and having the praise heaped on by every man and his dog, but there are still understandable and justified concerns over his capacity to compete as a top flight centre-back.
One thing is for certain; he’s a very, very good prospect. He’s got clear quality and potential, but may not quite be ready for the biggest stage of them all just yet. His inconsistencies have shown in the ten senior appearances and it can’t come as a surprise to anyone. He’s been thrown in at the deep end, effectively.

It’s a strange one regarding Stephens, but a pattern has been somewhat noticeable. He’s had exceptional games against Daniel Sturridge and Jermain Defoe, along with a comfortable game against Jamie Vardy. However, he’s had some extremely iffy moments and underwhelming matches against Fernando Llorente and Andy Carroll.
Physical strikers seem to overpower Stephens at the moment, and it looks as though he’s far better suited to taking care of the more mobile, dynamic attackers. So, the match up against against Ibrahimovic may just be a stretch too far for the youngster. It’d be the biggest game of his, and many others on Saints’ team, career and it would simply be an enormous duty for a player of his inexperience.
However, it could quite easily be argued that he’s a more straight-forward, reasonable inclusion at the back than Caceres is. After all, he’s been part of the setup for some time now, knows exactly what Puel wants from him and has formed something of a partnership with Yoshida over the last few weeks. Perhaps he’d be the more pragmatic option for the game.

In all honesty, Puel really can’t win here. Of course, he’s got the tactical responsibility of selecting the team and lining them up in the way in which United can be defeated, but picking Yoshida’s partner for the game at Wembley is always going to divide opinion. He’ll get criticism regardless, when the team sheets come out.
If he starts Stephens? He’s too young and Caceres is far superior and Ibrahimovic will eat him alive and it’s the end of the world and Puel’s an idiot.
If he starts Caceres? He’s risking his condition for the rest of the season, he’s thrown him in under too difficult circumstances, he should have played Stephens, the board need to go, the world’s going to end.
In this sense, Puel can’t win. But I’m glad he has more than one option to choose from, because I’m not a fan of Gardos coming in for such a game and to start a slightly smaller Ryan Bertrand in central defence would be just asking for it, really…
As I’ve previously alluded to though, the training camp out in Spain is sure to bear huge influence. With double sessions every day, a larger timescale to explain his tactical approach prior to the match and the opportunity to oversee just what condition Caceres is in, Puel will benefit from the trip.

The risky nature of football will simply be epitomised in situations such as these, and it’s certain to be a monumental occasion for the club and particularly whoever partners Yoshida at the back for Saints.
And that’s another point… six months ago, who’d have thought that Maya Yoshida would be the undisputed starter in central defence for a coveted cup final?!
Football is a funny old game, but we should back Puel on whoever he opts to use when February 26 comes, because it’s a decision that requires meticulous analysis prior to the clash and a decision that only a manager can make.
Whether it be Caceres or Stephens, let’s just hope they’ll both be lifting the EFL Cup next week.









Comments.
Loading comments…