---
title: "These Southampton fans react to McCarthy’s performance against Man City"
canonical: "https://readsouthampton.com/2019/11/03/these-southampton-fans-react-to-mccarthys-performance-against-man-city/"
type: "post"
language: "en-GB"
author: "Daniel Emery"
section: "Feature Writers"
published: "2019-11-03T19:00:09Z"
modified: "2019-11-03T19:00:09Z"
---

# These Southampton fans react to McCarthy’s performance against Man City

Southampton manager Ralph Hasenhuttl opted to drop goalkeeper Angus Gunn in the club’s 2-1 defeat to Manchester City on Saturday.

He went with experienced shot-stopper Alex McCarthy in his place, who produced a solid display between the sticks – although he was partly to blame for City’s winner.

These Southampton fans reacted to his performance…

100%…

> Twitter: Today proves exactly why McCarthy is 100% better then Gunn. #SaintsFC (@C0AKESY)

Sooner…

> Twitter: McCarthy, totally justified, been saying it all season, saw it early doors, shame it wasn’t done sooner, I’m sure w… https://t.co/Tr7OZDqGoZ (@Sainty99)

Keep him…

> Twitter: McCarthy right choice too- let’s keep him in the side please #saintsfc (@Rosedym)

![Alex Livesey/Getty Images Sport](https://media.readsouthampton.com/readsouthampton/2019/11/1184246814-2.jpg)

Should have…

> Twitter: McCarthy… Should have been playing all season. #saintsfc (@andydavis1978)

### READ SOUTHAMPTON VERDICT

Angus Gunn is still a very young goalkeeper and needs support at this time in his career, rather than constant criticism for his mistakes. Hasenhuttl was right to bring him out of the firing line and put in McCarthy, who has plenty of Premier League experience and is reliable in goal.

Gunn needs a spell on the sidelines to get his head straight and be able to come back ready to perform again. He has had a rough start to the season, but he also impressed many times last season and has proven that he is capable of performing at this level.
