---
title: "Quickfire Takeaways – Southampton 0-5 Arsenal"
canonical: "https://readsouthampton.com/2017/01/29/quickfire-takeaways-arsenal-0-5-southampton/"
type: "post"
language: "en-GB"
author: "Luke Osman"
section: "Feature Writers"
published: "2017-01-29T18:29:31Z"
modified: "2017-01-29T20:18:10Z"
---

# Quickfire Takeaways – Southampton 0-5 Arsenal

Southampton were battered last night in the FA Cup fourth round by Arsenal 5-0 and it’s safe to say that a packed St Mary’s Stadium crowd were frustrated by many things on the night.

A brace from Danny Welbeck fired Arsenal ahead, whilst Theo Walcott piled on the misery for Saints with a well-taken hat-trick.

Without further ado – as I don’t really want to talk much more about the game – here are my thoughts.

* * *

**Hero to zero –** It’d only be right to start with Claude Puel. Everyone was praising him after the EFL Cup success, but he totally stunned everyone yesterday with his team selection. He made ten changes and fielded a joke of a team, if I’m honest. We got what we deserved in a 5-0 loss and it was most certainly Puel’s fault.

**Heavy rotation –** What I will say, is that Puel had to rotate yesterday. I would have prioritised Swansea on Tuesday over Arsenal yesterday too. However, did he really need to change everything? Everyone was on a high after Wednesday night and he totally brought the mood down with the team selection. Change a few things here and there, rest those who actually need it, and give opportunities to some young players – but put some thought into it.

The team looked like it had just been chucked together with a mix of fringe players, a couple experienced ones, and the remainder filled with academy products. Poor management.

**Gulf in class –** It’s worth mentioning that Arsenal also made ten changes. The difference? They still had top drawer players on show. Theo Walcott, Danny Welbeck and Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain compared to Josh Sims, Shane Long and Lloyd Isgrove. Oh, and they brought on Alexis Sanchez.

![Julian Finney/Getty Images Sport](https://cdn.readeverything.cohttps//media.readsouthampton.com/readsouthampton/2017/01/632917602.jpg)

You can’t show a team like Arsenal the disrespect of fielding a second – or maybe even third – string side without expecting a battering.

**Florin Gardos –** The big Romanian defender made his first senior appearance in a whopping 23 months yesterday and if I’m honest – whilst I’ll be in a minority here – I didn’t actually think he did too badly. Sure, it wasn’t great and he was rusty, but it could have been a lot worse. His fitness looked fine, which was a plus.

**Too much impetus on youth –** Saints are renowned for their nurturing of the younger players, but I can’t help but feel as though some may just need to be tested elsewhere before being called upon.

Harry Lewis will have been demoralised by last night’s game, but it’s clear to see he isn’t ready. He’d benefit from a loan to a League One side, for me.

Another that I feel could benefit from a temporary move is, and I can’t believe I’m saying this, Harrison Reed. Whilst I think that he has more than enough to succeed as a Premier League player, he simply won’t get regular game time here for a while. I can’t help but feel as though if he can spend half a season, or a whole season, on loan at a Championship club, he’d come back as an even better and more refined player.

![Alex Livesey/Getty Images Sport](https://cdn.readeverything.cohttps//media.readsouthampton.com/readsouthampton/2017/01/631659778.jpg)

**Cuco Martina –** It was a game that simply required leaders and the senior pros had to step up and provide that. Martina? Christ. He’s right up there with the worst players I’ve seen at the club. For the majority of the game, he was either up on the right wing or he was coming inside to central defensive midfield. Where was he? Championship player at best.

**Last but not least… –** Lloyd Isgrove. 24-years-old. Never actually broken into the first-team. Why is he still here? He can’t rely on ‘potential’ any more, because he’s 24. Needs to part ways with the club to save his career.
